American Idol
Letters link
Mailbag column today, focusing on the matter of Jack's father in the "Lost" finale and the "Idol" finale time overrun.
American Idol
American Idol
The talk about the American Idol winner thread
I was asked not to write a liveblog style story on the finale this year and instead do a straight news story on who won, but feel free to comment on the unsurprising result or anything else that happened on the finale -- like the way the show threw Antonella
American Idol
American Idol: Top 2
My thoughts on the Jordin rout are already up at NJ.com, but you can talk about the show here.
American Idol
American Idol: Who are these people
Today's column previews tonight's not-so-epic showdown between Blake and Jordin by talking about how the contestants have become surprisingly marginalized on the show. (As the great Lisa De Moraes points out again today, there was one results show where the contestants got less than five minutes
American Idol
American Idol: Top 3 results
My access to the NJ.com blog is down at the moment, so I'm just going to post my "Idol" thoughts here. Irritating spoilers to follow... Need proof? Look to last night’s “American Idol” results, when Melinda Doolittle – by far the season’s best singer
American Idol
American Idol: Top 3
Over the previous five seasons of "American Idol," a distinct pattern has emerged about Top 3 Night: whoever sings first gets eliminated. Every single time. Nikki McKibbin, Kimberley Locke, Jasmine Trias, Vonzell Solomon and Elliott Yamin all went first on this night, and all went home. Your "
American Idol
American Idol: Top 4 results
Thoughts on the predictable results are over at NJ.com, but you can talk about the show here.
American Idol
American Idol open thread 5/8
Since I'll be on a plane during the entirety of Bee Gees Night, I'll make a few link suggestions and then leave it to y'all. First, USA Today's week-in-the-life-of-"Idol" story gives away most of tonight's song choices,
American Idol
American Idol: Top 6 results, take two
Some thoughts on the "American Idol" results: See, America? You spend months freaking out about Sanjaya's hair, Haley's legs, Antonella's photos, Sanjaya's mustache, Sundance's red face, more of Antonella's photos, Vote for the Worst, Howard Stern,
American Idol
American Idol: Top 6, take two (Bon Jovi Night
Thoughts on the awesomeness of Melinda, the comeback of LaKisha, the stunning lousiness of Jordin and more from Bon Jovi Night, are up at NJ.com, but you can comment here.
American Idol
American Idol: Top 6 non-results
NJ.com is once again being buggy, so I'm going to duplicate what I wrote there over here. Thoughts on what did and didn't happen coming up after the jump... "How could we let anybody go on a charity night?" asked "American Idol&
American Idol
American Idol: Top 6 (Idol Gives Back)
Thoughts on part one of Idol Gives Back are up at NJ.com, but you can comment about it here.