From now through June 21, get $20 off an annual What's Alan Watching? subscription!
A review of the Widow's Bay season finale, "Hope You Enjoyed Your Time!" — with spoilers — coming up just as soon as I thank you for your sacrifice...
Alan Sepinwall
When I first watched "Hope You Enjoyed Your Time!" almost two months ago, my initial response was that it felt like perhaps Widow's Bay was a story most optimally told over just one season, and that the finale was a somewhat underwhelming attempt to extend things past that. But as I've revisited the whole season in writing these recaps, and as I've thought a lot about this episode lately, my opinion has shifted a lot in favor of both the finale and the idea of the series as an ongoing project.
First, it really does feel like we've just scratched the surface of all the horrors the island has to offer. The finale alone introduces (or, at least, expands on prior hints about) multiple different problems. Dale(*) discovers evidence of the community's ritual human sacrifices meant to appease the island — a process that for a while was so systematic, there was even an industrial film made to show to the poor suckers chosen for it. ("So, you're an offering," it hilariously begins.) Meanwhile, Evan and his friends find the same ominous chair in the underground catacombs that we've glimpsed earlier in the season. Nothing bad happens to them, but when Evan's buddy locks a custodian in the room as what he thinks is a harmless prank, Evan can overhear something awful happening to the guy through the door. We've seen a handful of the monsters at play, but there's clearly a very rich mythology here. I don't mind that, thanks to Apple's order for a second season, we'll get to learn more about everything.