This week's Friday Check-In newsletter coming up just as soon as I James Bond it into the drop ceiling...
In The Twilight Zone Zone

The Serling book tour has another stop for those of you in the New York/New Jersey area. I'll be at the Wyckoff Public Library in Wyckoff, NJ on December 1. More details here:

I also did a virtual appearance at the Dearborn Public Library earlier this week. When they post the video to their YouTube channel, I'll put it here.
Catching up
Here's what I've published since last Friday's newsletter:
- In the latest TV Is Good podcast episode, Kathryn and I did a triple feature on shows set in quirky small towns, focusing on Best Medicine and North of North as two different creative descendants of Northern Exposure (even if Best Medicine is technically a remake of Doc Martin).

- With this weekend's premiere of the fourth and final season of Yellowjackets, I was prompted to look back at the complicated and ultimately disappointing legacy of Showtime, the premium cable channel where Yellowjackets debuted:

- I recapped the penultimate episode of The Lowdown Season Two, where Lee worked through his grief in surprisingly hilarious ways:

What's next?
It's a short holiday week, with a surprising amount of content, including:
- In the next TV Is Good episode, Kathryn and I talk about The Altruists, though you'll get some of my thoughts on it later in this newsletter, then rewind a few years for the once-again timely Hulu miniseries The Dropout, starring Amanda Seyfried as Theranos scammer Elizabeth Holmes.
- I'll be reviewing the new Peacock comedy Dig, reuniting Parks and Recreation co-creator Michael Schur and Parks and Rec star Amy Poehler.
- I have a cool announcement about my book about The Wire.
- With The Lowdown season finale dropping, you'll be getting not only my recap, but interviews with both Ethan Hawke and creator Sterlin Harjo.
There will also be a Black Friday Check-In of some sort, but probably brief. For those of you traveling on Thanksgiving, do it safely. And if there's more airport mayhem, may cable news send this guy to cover it:
Showtime no more, redux

If you read that Showtime piece, you may have noticed an unusually high number of parentheticals, italicized asides, and other kinds of tangents from the main thesis. This is what happens when I wrote a piece that covers decades' worth of shows on a channel I watched an awful lot. As it is, I had to kill a few darlings here and there. But what is the Friday Check-In for, if not a place in which I can publish all the stray thoughts that got cut from the original piece?
- As I wrote on Tuesday, you could define both Showtime and most of its series as "almost, but not quite." Outside of Twin Peaks: The Return and The Good Lord Bird, both of which were miniseries, even the very best seasons of Showtime shows never really were creatively competitive with their HBO peers — A- versus an A or A+. And a lot of the shows in that B- to B+ range had a handful of compelling elements that never quite came together. One I think about a lot in this vein is Kidding, starring Jim Carrey as a Mister Rogers-esque children's show host struggling with grief after the death of one of his twin sons and the dissolution of his marriage. Carrey was wonderful. The first few episodes were directed by Michel Gondry, in an Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind reunion with Carrey, and pretty perfectly married the whimsy and melancholy of the premise. But you could feel the creative team struggling with that balance after Gondry left, and also with how much Carrey's Jeff Pickles should feel like a real person versus a larger-than-life enigma. In its best moments, it felt like it could be something special. But, like a lot of Showtime series, its best moments came far too intermittently.
- We've all got a song, or a show, or a meal, that we have fond memories of, but worry that if we tried it again years later, it wouldn't remotely live up to our memories. For me, it's an almost entirely forgotten Showtime dramedy from 2001 called Going to California, about two buddies from a small Massachusetts town on a seemingly never-ending road trip. My wife and I watched every episode, and still quote a few lines from it to each other on occasion. But it never made it to home video, and even its great Old 97's theme song, "Lost Along the Way," never got released. (I saw the band's frontman Rhett Miller play a solo show in Jersey earlier this year and asked him about it; he lamented that they sold all rights to the song to one of the entities that produced the show.) Even at the time, I don't think I thought of it as great, and certainly not deep, but I found the chemistry between stars Sam Trammell and Brad Henke to be charming, and I liked the no-stakes Fugitive vibes of it, where odd things happened to them in each small town they visited. I went looking for a clip to embed here, and instead discovered that someone has of course posted all 20 episodes to a YouTube playlist. I'm half-intrigued, half-afraid to watch and have my old memories spoiled. But they're there if anyone wants to dive in and report back.
- Going to California was originally developed as a pilot for the WB, with Abraham Benrubi in the Brad Henke role. In later years, a lot of shows developed at Showtime would wind up elsewhere. In the column, I mentioned how Halo got turned into a Paramount+ original. But there was also Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, which might have been more explicit on Showtime but would have lost some of the comedy that came from Rachel Bloom and company figuring out how to work within the limits of the CW's censors. And as Showtime underwent several leadership changes in the brand's dying years, several would-be Showtime awards players got sold off to other outlets: Ripley with Andrew Scott went to Netflix, for instance, and Three Women with Shailene Woodley and Betty Gilpin eventually aired on Starz.
Curious if any of you have any Showtime deep cuts you still think about affectionately.
Pump up the scam
Finally, let's talk a little about The Altruists. You'll get a more robust discussion of it in Monday's podcast, but (spoiler) Kathryn liked it a lot more than I do.
Anthony Boyle and Julia Garner play, respectively, Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison, off and on partners in both love and crimes — Sam as the founder of crypto giant FTX, and Caroline running FTX's sister company, Alameda Research. Sam and Caroline hit it off at first because both are brilliant, both are socially awkward, and both believe deeply in the concept of effective altruism — that it's a basic social good to make as much money as possible, so long as you give virtually all of it away to charity. As Sam realizes that he can make a fortune in the crypto space, he and Caroline begin cutting ethical corners, each time insisting these minor sins are in service of a greater good. They are willfully blind to the slippery slope they're descending, which will eventually result in the theft of $8 billion in customer's money. At the same time, their romantic relationship is on again and off again, complicated by her mathematically-tested belief in polyamory, his painful self-doubt, her obsession with writing Harry Potter fanfic, and his fear that it's inappropriate for them to be both lovers and business partners.
There's some good stuff here, particularly a later episode that spotlights Alex Lawther from The End of the F***ing World as a friend and colleague of Sam's who has a clearer view of what Sam and Caroline are doing. But there isn't enough story to fill eight hours, with the same basic conflicts and themes repeated to the point of diminishing returns. And the decision to tell the story out of order, bouncing between the halcyon early days of FTX and its scandalous destruction, detracts far more than it adds. If you don't go into the miniseries with a deep understanding of crypto, the non-linear narrative makes a confusing subject all but impenetrable, while also undercutting the emotional story between Sam and Caroline that's ultimately the primary concern of Graham Moore, who adapted reporting from New York Magazine for the show.
Then there's Garner. I think she's one of the best young actors we have working today. But her greatest strength is her ability to access raw emotions and make them palpable to the viewer, not being a chameleon. She was terrible in another scammer miniseries, playing Anna Delvey in Netflix's Inventing Anna. Her performance here is a too self-conscious piece of nerd drag.
That said, in most individual scenes, it's super watchable. My patience for it just ebbed long before I got to the end of it.
That's it for today! What does everybody else think?



