Skip to content

TV Is Good, Episode 5: Is 'Widow's Bay' more cursed than 'Gilligan's Island'?

TV Is Good, Episode 5: Is 'Widow's Bay' more cursed than 'Gilligan's Island'?

Welcome back to the TV Is Good podcast, where Kathryn and I loaded up on dramamine this week to travel to two remote, cursed islands.

Widow’s Bay recap, Episode 9: ‘Emergency Shelter’
A storm hits the island as Season One heads into its endgame

First, we talked about Widow's Bay Season One to date, and why we think it's become the water cooler hit of the spring. (We also talk about what a better 2026 phrase would be, since hanging around the office water cooler is no longer really a thing.) There are some spoilers in there, but we start out with more general talk about why we like it, and there's a warning before we get into what's happened leading up to this week's finale.

So far, we're trying to make sure each week's classic show is thematically paired in some way with the current show. When we were plotting out this episode, I jokingly suggested we should follow the Widow's Bay discussion with some Gilligan's Island talk. Kathryn then immediately seized on this as a great idea, and it turns out that she was right. Just a ridiculous conversation about two of the most ridiculous episodes of an iconically ridiculous TV show.

We also talk a bit about the death of Anthony Stewart Head (which happened after we recorded last week's Buffy discussion). In that segment, I mentioned the coffee commercials he starred in in the Nineties, and mistakenly said they were for Taster's Choice. Instead, they were Nescafé:

You can watch the episode on YouTube:

You can stream the audio right here:

Or you can subscribe to TV Is Good wherever you get your podcasts:

TV Is Good
Television criticism from Alan Sepinwall & Kathryn VanArendonk

Our Patreon is at Patreon.com/TVIsGoodPod. Our poll last week resulted in the subscribers choosing The Americans series finale, "START," as the topic for next month's bonus episode, which will drop on Monday, July 6.

The podcast also has its own social media accounts on InstagramBlueSkyThreads, and TikTok.

To quote the hosts of every show you listen to say, please remember to subscribe, rate/like, and review, because the algorithm uses that data to decide what shows to promote to people who don't already know about them. Please help us beat the algorithm at its own game. You can also write to the two of us specifically at tvisgoodpod@gmail.com.

Alan Sepinwall

Alan Sepinwall

Alan Sepinwall is a TV critic and editor of What's Alan Watching? His books include The Revolution Was Televised, The Sopranos Sessions, TV (THE BOOK), Breaking Bad 101, Saul Goodman v. Jimmy McGill, and Welcome to The O.C.